Asterhäll  /  Get in Shape  /  Nutrition

Protein Bar or Candy Bar? How “Healthy” Snacks Fool Us

Nutrition · Healthy  ·  Nov 15, 2026  ·  6 min read

Walk into any supermarket or petrol station and they are there, right next to the till: protein bars in black and silver wrappers with words like high protein, no added sugar and fitness. One shelf further down lie Snickers and Japp, the ones we have learned to feel guilty about.

But how big is the difference really? We put a popular protein bar, two classic chocolate bars and our own homemade bar next to each other and looked at what the labels actually say.

The comparison

All values are per bar, taken from the manufacturers' labels (the homemade bar is calculated from our recipe). Prices are approximate Swedish shelf prices in November 2026 and vary between shops.

Per barBarebells Salty PeanutSnickersJapp (double)Homemade power bar
Weight55 g50 g60 gabout 55 g
Energy203 kcal240 kcal265 kcalabout 185 kcal
Protein20 g4.3 g2 gabout 4 g
Sugars1.5 g + maltitol26 g32 gabout 25 g (from dates)
Fat8.5 g11.5 g9 gabout 4.5 g
Fibre3.1 gabout 1 g0.7 gabout 4 g
Priceabout 26 krabout 13 krabout 15 krabout 7 kr
Price per kgabout 470 krabout 250 krabout 250 krabout 125 kr

What the numbers tell us

Read the ingredient list, not the front

The front of the wrapper is marketing. The ingredient list on the back is the law, and the ingredients are listed in order of weight. This is the protein bar's list, in order:

Milk proteins, humectant (glycerol), collagen hydrolysate, sweeteners (maltitol, sucralose), polydextrose, water, cocoa butter, whole milk powder, roasted peanut pieces, peanut paste (3.2%), sunflower oil, cocoa mass, fat-reduced cocoa, flavourings, salt, emulsifier (lecithins).

The peanut on the front makes up just over three percent. Most of the bar is milk protein powder, glycerol to keep it soft, collagen, sweeteners and polydextrose, a fibre made in a factory. These are not dangerous ingredients, but they are not food you could make in your own kitchen. That is exactly what researchers mean by ultra-processed food.

One more detail: collagen is counted as protein on the label, but it lacks the amino acid tryptophan and is a poor building block for muscle. Part of the 20 grams is therefore worth less than it looks. Read more in Amino acids explained.

The words that fool us

Why ultra-processed food matters

In a well-known study at the US National Institutes of Health (Hall et al., 2019), 20 adults lived in a research ward and ate either ultra-processed or minimally processed food for two weeks each, as much as they wanted. On the ultra-processed diet, they ate about 500 kcal more per day and gained weight, even though the meals had the same amount of sugar, fat and fibre on offer. On the other diet, they lost weight.

A large umbrella review in the BMJ in 2024 (Lane et al.), with almost ten million participants, linked a high intake of ultra-processed food to a higher risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, depression and early death. It does not prove that a single bar is harmful, but it shows the direction: the more of our food comes from factories, the worse we seem to do.

So, which should you choose?

The simplest rule? The fewer words on the back, the better the food. An apple and a handful of nuts have no ingredient list at all.

Sources: Barebells, Salty Peanut product information and ingredients (barebells.com, November 2026); Mars, Snickers 50 g label (ICA, Sweden); Marabou, Japp label (Dabas product sheet); Hall KD et al., ultra-processed diets cause excess calorie intake and weight gain, Cell Metabolism 2019; Lane MM et al., ultra-processed food exposure and adverse health outcomes: umbrella review, BMJ 2024; Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 on nutrition and health claims; Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 on food information to consumers (labelling of polyols); Livsmedelsverket, sweeteners and sugar alcohols. Prices are approximate and vary between shops. This article is general information and does not replace advice from your doctor or a dietitian.